How Important Are Enjoyment and Mobility for continuance with mobile date services.docx
《How Important Are Enjoyment and Mobility for continuance with mobile date services.docx》由会员分享,可在线阅读,更多相关《How Important Are Enjoyment and Mobility for continuance with mobile date services.docx(37页珍藏版)》请在冰点文库上搜索。
![How Important Are Enjoyment and Mobility for continuance with mobile date services.docx](https://file1.bingdoc.com/fileroot1/2023-5/1/566aa989-2b26-43f2-b34f-7bef13776ca2/566aa989-2b26-43f2-b34f-7bef13776ca21.gif)
HowImportantAreEnjoymentandMobilityforcontinuancewithmobiledateservices
HowImportantAreEnjoymentandMobilityfor
ContinuancewithMobileDataServices?
JuneLu*
SchoolofBusinessAdministration
UniversityofHouston-Victoria
luj@uhv.edu
ChangLiu
CollegeofBusiness
NorthernIllinoisUniversity
cliu@niu.edu
JuneWei
CollegeofBusiness
UniversityofWestFlorida
Email:
jwei@uwf.edu
*:
Correspondingauthor
HowImportantAreEnjoymentandMobilityfor
ContinuancewithMobileDataServices?
Abstract:
Thispaperinvestigatesthefactorsimpactingusers’continuanceintentionsonusingmobiledataservices.Specifically,asecond-stagecontinuancemodelisrevisedandtestedwithafocusonbothhedonicandutilitarianneeds.Theconstructsofenjoymentandmobilityareusedtoderiveasetofhypotheses.Aninstrumentisdevelopedtocollectdatafrom584subjects.Statisticalanalysessuchasstructuralequationmodelingareconductedoncollecteddataforhypothesestesting.Thefindingsshowthatbothutilitarian(mobility)andhedonic(enjoyment)constructshelptopredictcontinuanceintentiontowardmobiledataservicesviasmartphones.Thesalienceofdisconfirmationandbeliefsinmobilityandenjoymentdrivessatisfactionandattitudechangestowardcontinuanceintentions.Moreover,perceivedmobility,enjoymentandsatisfactionconstructsjointlyexplainedalmost80percentofthevarianceinpost-usageattitude.Theoreticalandpracticalimplicationsarealsopresentedanddiscussed.
Introduction
Withrapidproliferationof3Gand4Gwirelessbroadbandnetworksandmobiledevicessuchassmartphonesandtabletcomputers,mobileInternetdataservicesareenjoyingthelevelofpopularitywhichwasneverexperiencedbyanypreviousmobilecomputingtechnologies.Amobiledevice,bycommonunderstanding,referstoasmall,hand-heldcomputingdevice,typicallyhavingadisplayscreenwithtouchinputand/oraminiaturekeyboardandweighinglessthan2pounds.Smartphones,PersonalDigitalAssistances(PDA)s,Tabletcomputers,Ultra-mobilePCs,andwearablecomputersarejustafewexamples.Thosedevicessupportvariousmobiledataservicesoverawidegeographicareatoenableexchangeofmessages,pictures,videos,ande-mail,hotelreservations,managingflightschedules,bookingconcerttickets,andplayingonlinegameswhileontheroad.AccordingtoaNielsenCompanyreport,theUSbecamethegloballeaderinmobileInternetadoptionin2008.Presently,theUnitedStateshasfarmoretotaldevicesconnectedtotheInternetthananyothercountry(Worldwide,mobileInternetaccountedformorethan10percentoftotalInternetusagein2012,hadincreasedfromjust3.8percentin2010,whichistestamenttothegrowingadoptionofmobiledevices(PewResearchCenter,awell-knownnonprofit"facttank"thatprovidesinformationonthetrendsshapingAmericaandtheworld,declaredinDecember2012that45%Americanadults,66%youngadults(18-29),68%inhouseholdsearning$75,000ormorearemobileusers(http:
//pewinternet.org/Commentary/2012/February/Pew-Internet-Mobile.aspx).MorganStanley’smobileInternetresearchreport(2011)revealedthatU.S.hasovertakenJapanin3Guserbase.And3Gsubscriberpenetrationwillgrowover40%by2014,concentratedindevelopednations.AlltheevidencepointstothesamefactthatmobileusershavereachedacriticalmassintheU.S.
Sincetheturnofthiscentury,agoodnumberofresearchstudieshavebeendonetopredictandexplainuseradoptionofwirelessmobiledataservices(Lu,Yu,Liu,&Yao,2003;Lu,Yu,&Yao,2005;Lu,Liu,Yu,&Wang,2008;Venkatesh,Thong,&Xu,2012).Withmobilephonesmoredata-focused,moreusersarepredictedtoconnecttotheInternetwithwirelessdevicesthandesktopPC’swithinfiveyears(MorganStanley,2011).Ontheotherhand,MobileWebaccesstodaystillsuffersfrominteroperability,connectionandusabilityproblems.UserretentionandloyaltyappeartobecriticalindeterminingthefateofmobilelifeintheageofthewirelessInternet.Itisthehightimetoexaminetheperceptions,satisfactionandcontinuanceintentionsofmobileInternetdataserviceusers.
Priorresearchhassuggestedthatcontinueduseisnotsimplyanextensionoftheadoptiondecisionandthatthesetwobehaviorsarenotmediatedbythesameantecedentsthatpredicttheadoptiondecision(seeAjzenandFishbein2005,Limayemetal.2007).Overtime,asusersgainfirst-handexperiencewithinformationtechnology(IT)usage,theyevaluatetheextenttowhichtheirinitialcognitionisinagreementordisagreementwithactualexperience,andrevisetheircognitionand/orbehaviortoachievegreateragreement.Conventionalwisdomheldbymarketingpractitionershaslongrevealedthatretainingcurrentcustomersiseasierandmorecosteffectivethangainingnewcustomers.Users,obviously,oughttotakeanactivepartindeterminingthefateofmobilelifeintheageofthewirelessInternet.
Researchershaveattemptedtoidentifywhichantecedentsaremostcriticaltocontinueduseandhowcontinuedusecanchangeattitudesthathavebeenfoundtobeimportantpredictorsofadoptionintention(ChiuandWang2008,LimayemandCheung2008).Ourpreliminaryliteraturereviewrevealsveryfewusercontinuancestudiesinmobilecontext;andthosepublishedrecentlyareallconductedinothercountries(Baek,Park,andLee,2011;Choi,Kim,andKim,2011;Zhou,2011;Venkatesh,Thong,&Xu,2012).VeryfewcontinuancestudiesuseAmericanmobileInternetuserssofar.Thus,thereissomeevidentlackofunderstandingofusercontinuanceintentionswithmobileInternetservicesintheU.S.whichhasthehighestpenetrationrateworldwideformobiledevices;lackofunderstandingofthefactorsinfluencingtheircontinuanceintentions.
Theaimofthisstudyistwo-folded:
(1)torevealifactualusageexperienceimpactsuserperceptionstowardmobiledataservices;and
(2)toexploreiftheutilitarianandhedonicdeterminantsarebothimportantinthedecisionprocessoncontinuanceusageofmobiledataservices.Asatheoryguide,aprocessmodelwillbedevelopedtostudymobileInternetdataserviceusercontinuanceintentions.Studyofthisnatureshouldyieldimportanttheoreticalcontributions,aswellaspracticalimplications.
Toachievetheresearchpurpose,wefirstdiscusstherelevantliteratureandproposeourresearchmodelwithhypothesizedrelationships.Wethenproposeourresearchmethodologyanddataanalysisplantotestourresearchmodel.Afterreportingthetestresults,theimplicationsforresearchandpracticearealsodiscussed,priortoresearchlimitationsandfutureresearchdirections.
TheoryBackground
Users’post-adoptionbehaviorshaveemergedasakeytopicinISresearchinrecentyears.Priorstudiesproposedseveraltheoreticalmodels,includingtheexpectation-confirmationtheory(ECT),technologyacceptancemodel(TAM),unifiedtheoryofacceptanceanduseoftechnology(UTAUT),andthelatestintegrationofUTAUTandECTintheexpandedtwo-stagemodelofIScontinuance.Thesetheorieshaveonethingincommon-toexplainhowthedeterminantsarerelatedtoeachotherandcausallyinfluenceITusage.Thesemodelshelptolaythenomologicalnetworkofourresearchmodel.Ontheotherhand,withrecentbreakthroughsinbroadbandinfrastructure,interactivesoftwareandwirelessmobiletechnologies,thescopeandapplicationofIShaveexpandedbeyonditsoriginalutilitarianobjectivetoalsoencompassnon-utilitarianobjectives(LinandBhattacherjee,2010;Venkatesh,Thong,Chan,Hu,&Brown,2011;Venkatesh,Thong,&Xu,2012).Understandingofthehedonicsystemacceptancealsocontributestoinclusionofimportantconstructsinthecurrentmodel.
ECT
AkeytheoryexplainingcontinuedISusageisexpectation-confirmationtheory(ECT)(Bhattacherjee,2001).Originatedinmarketingtostudyconsumersatisfactionandpost-purchaseBehavior(e.g.Oliver,1980),ECTsuggeststhatconsumersfirstformaninitialexpectationofaproductorservicepriortopurchase.Afterthepurchasedecisionandaperiodofuse,consumerswillformperceptionsoftheperformanceoftheproductorservice.Next,consumerswillcomparetheperceivedperformancewiththeirinitialexpectationsanddeterminetheextenttowhichtheirexpectationsareconfirmed.Finally,basedontheirexpectationsandconfirmationlevels,consumersformasatisfactionassessmentthatinturnaffectstheirrepurchaseintention.ISusers’continuancedecisionsaresimilartoconsumers’repurchasedecisions,asbothtypesofdecisions
(1)followaninitialdecision;
(2)areinfluencedbytheusageexperience;and(3)canpotentiallyleadtoexpostreversaloftheinitialdecision(Bhattacherjee,2001).Themodelpositedthatcontinuanceintentionwasinfluencedbyusersatisfactionandpost-acceptanceusefulnessperceptions,whileusersatisfactionwasdeterminedbyconfirmationofexpectationsfromprioruse.Furthermore,confirmationinfluencedperceivedusefulness.ECThasbeenappliedtostudydifferentproblemsinIS,suchasIScontinuance(Bhattacherjee,2001),changesinusers’beliefsandattitudesduringthecourseofusage(Bhattacherjee&Premkumar,2004),post-usagesatisfaction(Susarlaetal.,2003)andextendeduseofcomplexIS(Hsieh&Wang,2007).
BasedontheECT,Bhattacherjee&Premkumar(2004)proposedatwo-stagemodelofIScontinuance,aprocessmodel,to